Pros and Cons of Buying Aged Final Expense Leads | Complete Guide

According to Statista, the U.S. life insurance industry spent over $6 billion on direct marketing in 2022. With increasing costs per lead, many agents are shifting focus to aged final expense leads as a cost-efficient alternative. These leads originate from prospects who once showed interest in coverage but weren’t converted at the time.

This guide outlines the pros and cons of buying aged final expense leads and how to make them profitable using smart tools and strategy.

Key Takeaways:

What Are Aged Final Expense Leads?

Aged final expense leads are older prospects, often seniors, who showed past interest in final expense insurance, whether via forms, ads, or call centers. They weren’t contacted or converted on time, making them cheaper but riskier. Leads are usually segmented by age: 30-day, 90-day, 6-month, or 1+ year-old.

Pros of Buying Aged Final Expense Leads:

1. Cost-Effective Outreach:

• Aged leads are priced between $0.50 and $5.
• Lower cost means less financial risk and higher ROI potential.

2. High Volume Access:

• Purchase leads in bulk to increase contact chances.
• Use data to refine targeting and messaging over time.

3. Lower Competition:

• Dormant leads are less likely to be in active sales cycles.
• A new approach can break through where others failed.

4. Sales Skill Development:

• Useful for agents practicing cold calling, objection handling, and script building.

5. Potential Conversions Still Exist:

• Many leads still require coverage.
• Life events and financial changes may renew interest.

Cons of Buying Aged Final Expense Leads:

1. Low Contact & Conversion Rates:

• Expect contact rates below 5%.
• Leads may have changed numbers or passed away.

2. Time-Intensive Process:

• Requires more calls, follow-ups, and effort than fresh leads.

3. Outdated or Invalid Data:

• Info may be wrong or the lead might already have insurance.

4. Skepticism or Resistance:

• Cold contacts may not recall prior engagement or feel annoyed.

5. Inconsistent Vendor Quality:

• Some vendors sell recycled or poorly filtered data.
• Overused lists reduce effectiveness.

How To Make Aged Final Expense Leads Work For You:

• Use Dialers & CRM Systems: Implement tools like Mojo Dialer, PhoneBurner, or GoHighLevel to improve speed and response tracking.
• Build Empathetic Scripts: “Hi [Name], a while ago you requested info on affordable final expense plans. Are you still exploring coverage options?”
• Segment and Prioritize: Start with leads under 90 days old, then test others in phases.
• Multi-Touch Follow-Up: Use calls, voicemails, emails, and direct mail to boost engagement.
• Work With Reputable Vendors: Test small batches before scaling. Look for vendors like Aged Leads Store, Lead Heroes, or Smart Financial.

Who Should Use Aged Final Expense Leads?

• New agents refining pitches
• Independent agents with limited budgets
• Call centers using power dialers
• Agencies focused on high-volume strategies

Not ideal for agents prioritizing high-ticket, warm leads, or long-term relationship selling.

Conclusion – Pros and Cons of Buying Aged Final Expense Leads:

Buying aged final expense leads presents a trade-off between cost-efficiency and conversion effort. While they come at a fraction of the price of fresh leads, they require persistence, smart automation, and vendor vetting to be effective. For agents willing to adapt their approach, aged leads can offer strong ROI and a steady lead source. By combining empathetic outreach with smart tools, these leads can turn from overlooked data into real sales opportunities.

FAQs: